Identity theft, the full saga


“Uhhh, what do you mean I need to send the government my high school transcripts?” I asked flatly.

Without missing a beat, I got a clearly read-straight-from-the-screen stock answer: “Well, you see ma’am…”

~~~

Let me back up.

(Quick disclaimer: this has the potential to be a VERY American email. I have no clue how identity theft -- ugh!! -- works anywhere else.)

Once a month, my husband Rodrigo and I sit down for what we very creatively call “monthly bills.” We look at our finances, confirm nothing is on fire, and go about our day.

Part of that is skimming my credit report.

And listed under new accounts, there it was: a gleaming, brand-spanking-new loan.

But not just any loan. A federal student loan.

Now, I’ve been out of school for over a decade. (Though I harbor not-so-secret desires to go back one day, just for fun.)

So I paused. Cocked my head to the side, squinted in the way my husband always tells me not to because it gives me headaches, and read it again.

“That’s… not mine.”

*Cue panic mode*

I immediately called AidVantage, the federal student loan agency listed under the loan, more than a little freaked out.

After word-vomiting my panic to the agent, I got the calmest, most in-control reply imaginable:

“Sounds like you’ve got a case of identity theft on your hands.”

Great. Love that for me.

Soooo what exactly am I supposed to do about it so I’m not stuck paying back a loan that is not mine??

The short answer: a LOT.

→ A police report

→ A fraud report with the Federal Trade Commission

→ An investigation opened with a university in New Hampshire where I was apparently enrolled as a student??

→ A very long “Loan Discharge Application: Forgery” form asking questions like who took out the loan in my name and what other pieces of my information they may have stolen (if I knew that, I wouldn’t be filling out this form, Mr. Government Agency)

→ Original or certified copies of my birth certificate, which are not always easy to get when you live in another state

→ A pile of other documents proving I am, in fact, me

And then, the transcripts. Not my college ones. But high school.

Believe it or not, there actually was a logical reason for it. (Though rest assured, I remain unhappy about it.)

And alas, after 5+ months and dozens of hours lost sorting it on my end, it’s still in process. 0/10, absolutely do not recommend.

But anyway. This whole “what do you MEAN I need to…?” feeling isn’t unique to federal paperwork and identity theft.

It’s basically a core part of running a business.

What do you MEAN I have to go out and market myself? (Clients don’t just land in my lap?!)

What do you MEAN I gotta deal with contracts, self-employment taxes, and chasing down invoices?

What do you MEAN my homepage headline can’t just say “Welcome!”?

What do you MEAN I need to figure out how to write my own copy on my website, sales pages, emails, and more AND it has to sound like me, convert my readers, AND not read like a robot wrote it?

That last one btw? I can help with that.

Paperwork involved: one short submission form. No birth certificates, no police reports, and definitely no high school transcripts.

My project calendar is booked out for now, but you can kick off 2027 by grabbing a ticket to the January Quick Copy Clinic or joining the Quarterly Copy Pass waitlist.

~Nicole

P.S. For my American friends: take 5 minutes and go check your credit report. Seriously.

linkedin

Nicole Elliott

Human-First Conversion Copy & Messaging Strategy

Non-salesy sales copy that sells w/out the sleaze  
emailAddress
hello@nicoleelliott.co
website
www.nicoleelliott.co

Unsubscribe | Update your profile | 600 1st Ave, Ste 330 PMB 92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2246

Nicole's Notes | A Newsletter by Nicole Elliott

Join the weekly (ish) newsletter for business owners who want their copy to sell without the sleaze, excessive sales pressure, or disappearing into the AI-flavored sea-of-sameness. Served alongside embarrassing personal stories, the occasional (okay fine, *frequent*) existential crisis, and at least one parenthetical aside per email.

Read more from Nicole's Notes | A Newsletter by Nicole Elliott

Didn’t grab a Quarterly Copy Pass a few weeks back? I’d love to know why. Take the 3-minute survey here (one respondent will win a free in-depth copy review + my eternal gratitude). Psst! I totally said this survey was closing Monday. But then I totally forgot to send a reminder. So, one more day it is! Well well well, Reader. This is it!! The final email!!! Are you as glad as I am that the Quarterly Copy Pass is closing today?? Because I’ve been in your inbox a lot this past week (thanks for...

Didn’t grab a Quarterly Copy Pass a few weeks back? I’d love to know why. Take the 3-minute survey here (one respondent will win a free in-depth copy review + my eternal gratitude). Psst! I totally said this survey was closing Monday. But then I totally forgot to send a reminder. So, one more day it is! I’ll be blunt, Reader. (Spoiler: this is about as “salesy” as I get in an email, so consider yourself warned accordingly ;-) Whether or not you grab a Quarterly Copy Pass by tonight’s...

Didn’t grab a Quarterly Copy Pass a few weeks back? I’d love to know why. Take the 3-minute survey here (one respondent will win a free in-depth copy review + my eternal gratitude). Psst! I totally said this survey was closing Monday. But then I totally forgot to send a reminder. So, one more day it is! Alright, folks. The Quarterly Copy Pass closes tomorrow. If you opened this email up, my guess is that you’re still on the fence. And totally fair! (I’m a chronic overthinker myself, so I...